7 of the Best Natural Eyeliners that Provide Rich Pigmented Color Without Smudging or Flaking
Makeup trends come and go, but the feline flick is a timeless classic for all of us. Even on your most unveiled days, you better believe that eyeliner will make you look put together, whether you want a sophisticated cat eye or a careless rocker look. If you decide to switch to a natural look, it’s definitely a good idea to start with beauty products that are close to the sensitive eye area. That’s why we cut back on the best natural eyeliners made by brands committed to clean and organic ingredients, ethical practices and eco-friendly packaging.
We chose products with a range of different shades and finishes that are waterproof, smudge-proof and ophthalmologist-tested to provide long-lasting color that won’t flake off in one go. They are the elite class.
Editor’s Choice
Milk Makeup Infinity Long-Wear Eyeliner
With Milk Makeup Eyeliner, you don’t have to be a makeup expert to create unlimited looks – whether it’s a sharp winged look or a smoky one. The retractable design and built-in curler and applicator allow you to create infinite looks in three easy steps. The effect? Intensely colored, well-defined eyes that won’t move for up to 12 hours. Waterproof and ophthalmologist-tested, the long-lasting and waterline safe formula is enriched with avocado oil, aloe vera extract and ceramides to provide a healthy, drag-free application.
Largest color range
Haus Labs Optical Strength Eco Gel Eyeliner
Available in 18 crazy shades, this eyeliner offers matte and shimmer finishes for a glamorous, sexy effect. The gel-like texture glides on like a liquid, deposits intense color and is clean and safe for the eye area, and the brush helps you blend it for an effortless, flawless look. You can use it for flicking, water lining, or even as an eyeshadow. Oh, and it’s waterproof, cruelty-free and as clean as possible.
The best organic formula
Au Naturale Organic Eyeliner
With shades from COSMOS and ECOCERT-approved mineral pigments, this natural eyeliner delivers rich, vibrant, long-lasting color that won’t smudge, warp or flake all day. Au Naturale Organic Eyeliner is available in eight shades, allowing you to draw out a glamorous eye look without looking sloppy – -a big hit. The soft tip formula allows you to glide effortlessly without pulling on your delicate skin, but is actually infused with jojoba and castor oils. Plus, this eyeliner comes with a built-in blending tool that lets you create a seductive smudging effect
Most Popular
Jane Iredale Mystikol Powder Eyeliner
This waterproof eyeliner is a great choice for your day and night. The powder-cream formula and built-in brush make it easy to create the perfect line or a long-lasting smoky eye look that won’t crease or smudge. And it’s vegan, with no traces of parabens, fragrances or other toxic ingredients. Plus, it has amazing payoff and is great for all-day wear. Speaking of colors, this natural eyeliner comes in four shades, from royal purple to chocolate brown and deep black, and you can also use it as an eyeshadow.
Best Liquid Formula
100% pure long-lasting liquid eyeliner
How does the idea of using an eyeliner infused with aloe vera, cocoa butter, rosemary and honeysuckle sound to you? Well, this eyeliner has it all. The clean (and waterproof) formula proudly features pigments from organic black tea leaves, ensuring that darker shades won’t fade throughout the day. The brush tip is small, perfect for a precise look, and reviewers praise its seamless glide on the lid. In addition, this eyeliner is vegan, natural, fragrance-free and cruelty-free. The only downside is the low color range.
The best gel formula
Ilia Natural Clean Line Eyeliner
Ilia nails it with this clean gel eyeliner that’s still there at the end of the day and glides on with ease and precision. According to the Harvard Department of Public Health, its high-intensity pigments are provided by charcoal powder, a natural alternative to charcoal black, an ingredient commonly found in traditional eyeliners and associated with eye problems . Most reviewers praise how easy it is to use and how well it stays in place all day. However, if you want a sharp eyeliner, then this may not be for you as it blends too easily.
Best for long wear
Bare Minerals Long-Lasting Eyeliner
Bare Minerals is the creator of clean beauty, nourishing skin with avocado oil and aloe vera extract for effortless application. The pencil-like applicator makes it easy to create any look, from precise lines to a smoky eye that won’t crease. Not only is its formula waterproof and smudge-proof, but this product is also designed to provide 12 hours of wear time. It comes in eight shades, which means the opportunities for fun looks are endless.
